Nov 16, 2026 • 10 min read

Heatmap Update

Heatmap Update
Photo by Dan Barrett / Unsplash

Investors are back to being bullish.

Our aggregate sentiment indicators dipped just below the 50 mark last week, moving into net bearish territory. But as equities rebounded, so did many of the sentiment indicators we track.

Our high-frequency Risk-on/Risk-off SMA, which uses inputs that refresh at least weekly, has bounced back to 58.3. That's a full 10 points above last week's low and puts investor sentiment at its most bullish level in a month.

That may be a big shift in just one week, but the bigger picture remains similar to what we have seen over most of the past month or two: Investor sentiment is moderately bullish, but still far from the historical extremes that have signalled poor equity returns ahead.

Given how short-lived the market and sentiment dip has been so far, we have essentially seen a round trip in many high-frequency indicators, such as implied volatility and put/call ratios. Meanwhile, most slower-moving indicators, particularly those with a monthly frequency, won't even pick up the move.

In practical terms, my interpretation is that sentiment is, at most, a small headwind for equity returns going forward. It is certainly not something I would build a bullish or bearish investment case around at this point.

Other factors should dominate the risk appetite discussion. What is your view on the global cycle? How strong will global growth be in the quarters ahead? Are you worried about a slowdown? And are there specific risks that could materialise over the next few months?

For now, those questions matter more than sentiment.


Top 3 This Week

1. Sentiment: Back to being bullish, but nothing extreme

Our high-frequency Risk-on/Risk-off SMA has rebounded 10 points from last week's low to 58.3, its most bullish reading in a month. But the bigger picture remains one of moderate bullishness, far from historical extremes.

2. European Equities: Outperformance is lifting sentiment

European equities have outperformed recently, pushing our Sentiment Matters Aggregate to the 71st percentile. That's clearly bullish, but not yet extreme. In the past three rallies, sentiment peaked above the 80th percentile.

3. Mexican Peso: A sharp reversal in sentiment

The Peso's depreciation has triggered a substantial shift in investor sentiment. Our SMA has fallen from the 90th to the 40th percentile, moving from extreme bullishness to neutral or slightly bearish territory. That's making the Peso more interesting from a contrarian perspective, although the historical buy threshold of the 14th percentile remains some distance away.


Sentiment Overview

Retail sentiment is heating up, or is it?

STAX, a US retail sentiment indicator based on Schwab client activity, rose this month.

At 61.9, the indicator is now at its most bullish level in five years. That's particularly interesting given that STAX rose against a backdrop of falling equity markets this month, which is unusual.

Historically, readings at this level have been consistent with somewhat below-average equity returns over the following year. However, we set the historical sell threshold at 68. In the 10 instances when STAX has reached that level, the S&P 500 has almost always delivered below-average returns over the subsequent 12 months.

So, one to keep an eye on, but not yet a yellow flag.

The New York Fed's consumer confidence survey paints a somewhat less bullish picture of retail sentiment.

The latest survey showed a small decline in stock market optimism, with 40% of consumers expecting US equities to be higher in a year's time. That's down marginally from the previous month.

A flat to slightly weaker reading in this survey arguably moderates the message we should take away from the STAX release.

It's also worth remembering that the most recent Conference Board survey showed a sideways move in consumer stock market optimism, albeit at a fundamentally more bullish level than the New York Fed's survey.

Margin debt: No warning signals

The latest FINRA margin debt data was broadly flat on the month and continues to look relatively benign.

Read the full story

Subscribe
Already have an account? Sign in
Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to Sentiment Matters.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.